In partnership with

GM. This is Needs to Exist (aka NTE), delivering you a startup idea that makes New Year’s habits measurable instead of motivational.

Start the year with NTE Pro - 6,500 ideas built for execution, not resolutions.

WhoFiled lands in your inbox so you see new raises before everyone else does.

Check out all the past newsletters here

Here’s what we’ve got for you today.

• Daily Idea - Stop Faking Habits

• The New Year’s Resolution Autopsy

Habit Apps Fail. Reality Doesn’t.

The One Liner

The habit tracker that doesn’t ask you to lie.

The 140 character tweet (or X) version

New Year’s resolutions fail because tracking is fake. This one measures real behavior automatically.

The Longer Story Version

The Problem

Every January we all do the same thing. We download a habit app, set ambitious goals, and tell ourselves this time it’s different. More steps. Less screen time. Better sleep. Smarter spending. The intentions are real.

The tracking is not.

Most habit apps quietly assume something that isn’t true: that people will consistently log their own behavior accurately. In practice, people forget. Or they’re busy. Or they “kind of” did the thing and tap yes anyway. Streaks survive. Truth doesn’t.

Over time, the data stops meaning anything. Progress becomes vibes. The app starts rewarding optimism instead of outcomes. And eventually guilt replaces motivation, which is the fastest way to uninstall something.

The real failure mode here isn’t discipline. It’s self-reporting. Asking humans to be perfectly honest and consistent about their habits is like asking social media users to only buy things they actually need. It sounds nice. It doesn’t happen.

The Solution

Instead of asking people what they did, remove the question entirely.

What if a habit app didn’t rely on willpower, memory, or honesty? What if it just measured what already happened using real signals that exist everywhere now?

Steps come from wearables.
Screen time comes from the phone itself.
Sleep comes from health devices.
Meditation comes from the apps people already use.
Spending and saving come from connected accounts.

Users don’t log habits. They generate data by living their lives.

Start narrow so trust stays high. Fitness and screen time first, because those are the habits people already try to fake the most. Once accuracy is obvious, expand slowly into sleep, mindfulness, and money. Add optional accountability partners or small groups, but keep it supportive instead of performative. No public streak shame. Just visibility when someone wants it.

The goal isn’t motivation. It’s removing friction from truth.

How We’d Build It

Phase 1: Prove the core insight
– Ship a stripped-down MVP that only does wearables + phone OS data
– Use a fast, flexible stack with a vibe-coding mindset (Supabase, Expo, or a Lovable-style builder)
– One dashboard, one promise: this data is real and automatic
– Obsess over trust, accuracy, and clarity

Phase 2: Make it useful
– Add deeper integrations most people don’t touch: HealthKit correlations, background OS permissions, Plaid category data
– Introduce opt-in accountability pairs and small groups
– Use lightweight AI to surface patterns instead of goals (“you sleep better on low-screen days”)

Phase 3: Make it scalable
– Expand habit categories carefully to avoid scope creep
– Personalize nudges based on behavior, not aspiration
– Lock in a simple $5/month subscription that feels trivial relative to the value
– Position it as infrastructure, not inspiration

Why It Needs to Exist
New Year’s resolutions don’t fail because people don’t care. They fail because most habit tools are built on polite lies.

The infrastructure finally exists to do this correctly. Wearables are everywhere. APIs are mature. People are tired of fake productivity and motivational theater. They want feedback that reflects reality, even when it’s uncomfortable.

This isn’t a hype app. It’s a mirror.

And for people who actually want to change something this year, that’s far more useful than another streak.

A free newsletter read by 117,000 marketers

The best marketing ideas come from marketers who live it.

That’s what this newsletter delivers.

The Marketing Millennials is a look inside what’s working right now for other marketers. No theory. No fluff. Just real insights and ideas you can actually use—from marketers who’ve been there, done that, and are sharing the playbook.

Every newsletter is written by Daniel Murray, a marketer obsessed with what goes into great marketing. Expect fresh takes, hot topics, and the kind of stuff you’ll want to steal for your next campaign.

Because marketing shouldn’t feel like guesswork. And you shouldn’t have to dig for the good stuff.

Sign Up Free

The New Year’s Resolution Autopsy

t’s mid-February.

The Peloton is dusty. The habit app hasn’t been opened in weeks. The resolution is officially dead.

So let’s do the autopsy.

On the table is a new kind of habit tracker. One that doesn’t ask you to log anything. It just measures what actually happened using wearables, phone data, and real signals. No streaks. No “did you do it today?” guilt.

Would this have saved the resolution? Or just delayed the funeral?

The Optimist goes first.

“Most habit trackers fail because they ask people to lie,” he says. “Manual input is the bug. This fixes that. If the app knows how much you walked, slept, or scrolled, you remove friction and remove self-deception. That alone changes behavior. People don’t need more motivation. They need accurate feedback.”

His argument is simple: truth compounds. When you see real data every day, patterns become obvious. You don’t need willpower if reality is staring back at you. For him, this is the first habit app that treats measurement like infrastructure, not a motivational poster.

Then the Realist leans in.

“This works for maybe 20% of people,” she says. “And those people were already pretty disciplined.”

Her concern isn’t technical. It’s psychological. Accurate data doesn’t automatically create change. For beginners, it might do the opposite. Seeing low numbers every day can feel like failure on repeat. At least manual trackers let people ease into a habit. This one removes the cushion.

She also questions retention. “Better charts don’t equal better habits. They equal better charts. If nothing in your life changes, you just get clearer evidence that nothing changed.”

Finally, the Coroner clears his throat.

“Here’s where it actually breaks.”

First, measurement can slide into surveillance fast. Even if users opt in, there’s a thin line between helpful reflection and feeling watched by your own phone. Second, not everything worth building a habit around can or should be measured. The app has to resist the urge to track everything just because it can.

And third, truth without context can be brutal. If the product doesn’t actively help users interpret the data, gently - it risks becoming a mirror people avoid.

But here’s the twist.

The autopsy concludes this idea didn’t fail because it’s wrong. It failed in most products because they started with hope. This one starts with failure. It assumes February is coming. It assumes motivation fades. It assumes people are human.

If built carefully starting narrow, making social features optional, prioritizing trust over growth, this doesn’t replace willpower. It replaces guesswork.

And maybe that’s enough to keep the next resolution alive just a little longer.

One More Meme