In partnership with

GM. This is Needs to Exist (aka NTE), delivering you a startup idea that turns cheap plastic trees into a local Christmas tradition.

NTE Pro: 6,500 startup ideas that make you think “wait… why doesn’t this exist?”

Whofiled: real funding filings that show you what’s getting built before it’s obvious.

Check out all the past newsletters here

Here’s what we’ve got for you today.

• Daily Idea - Christmas Tree Arbitrage

• Business or Tradition?

Buy Trees Cheap. Sell Christmas.

Inspired by the Koerner Office

The One Liner

Buy cheap trees. Sell a Christmas tradition.

The 140 character tweet (or X) version

Artificial trees are cheap in July. Families want them in December. Turn storage + timing into a local holiday business.

The Longer Story Version

The Problem

Artificial Christmas trees are bizarrely expensive when people actually want them.
And bizarrely worthless when they don’t.

In-season, new fake trees run $80–$300+.
Out of season, they pile up in liquidation warehouses, big-box back rooms, and Facebook Marketplace for pennies.

Retailers don’t want to store them.
Buyers don’t think ahead.
Families wait until Thanksgiving, then overpay.

At the same time, something else disappeared quietly:
The ritual of going to a tree lot.

People still want the experience.
They just don’t want needles in their carpet.

So we end up with a clean inefficiency hiding in plain sight:
Cheap inventory when nobody cares.
Predictable demand when everyone suddenly does.

That gap is the business.

The Solution

Buy artificial trees in the off-season.
Sell them locally with a vibe.

You source inventory in spring or summer for a few dollars a unit.
Store them in a garage, shed, or low-cost unit.
Then, for four weeks a year, you open a pop-up lot.

Not online.
Not dropshipped.
In a driveway, parking lot, or borrowed corner of town.

Trees priced at $30–$60 still feel like a deal.
Lights, signage, music, maybe a fire pit.
Hot chocolate, marshmallows, kids or teens helping run it.

You’re not selling plastic trees.
You’re selling “we do this every year now.”

You can layer in extras naturally:
Tree stands, skirts, lights.
Local wreaths.
A real-tree delivery partnership for neighbors who want both.
Charity tie-ins that make it feel civic, not commercial.

It’s arbitrage disguised as tradition.

How we’d build it

Phase 1: prove it works
Expertise: scrappy operator

Source inventory through liquidation sites, regional wholesalers, and under-the-radar Facebook reseller groups.
Use basic tools like Google Sheets for inventory, Square for payments, and a simple Carrd page for hours and directions.
Test demand with a small batch and one location. No brand. No ads. Just signs and word of mouth.

Phase 2: systemize
Expertise: local marketer

Standardize pricing, signage, and layout so it feels intentional.
Use tools like Notion for playbooks and Airtable for inventory tracking.
Spin up local Facebook and Nextdoor posts.
Let teens run operations with clear checklists.
Add simple upsells and partnerships.

Phase 3: scale
Expertise: operator + GTM

Turn it into a repeatable playbook other towns can copy.
License the model or franchise-lite it to families, schools, or community groups.
Centralize sourcing. Decentralize selling.
Seasonal capitalism, but clean.

The magic isn’t the trees.
It’s the sentence people say when they hear it:

“He’s opening an artificial Christmas tree lot in his town.”

That’s when you know it’s real.

Why it needs to exist

This works because it fits the moment perfectly.

Families are price-sensitive but still want nice things.
Liquidation markets are overflowing.
People crave local, nostalgic, low-stakes experiences.
Teens want seasonal work that isn’t soul-crushing.
Side hustles with fixed calendars are underrated.

The risks are boring and known:
You need storage.
You can’t miss the window.
You have to curate inventory so it doesn’t look junky.
Permits may exist depending on town.

Worst case, you wait another year.
Best case, you 5–10× your money in a month.

That asymmetry is rare.

Why AI Isn’t Replacing Affiliate Marketing After All

“AI will make affiliate marketing irrelevant.”

Our new research shows the opposite.

Levanta surveyed 1,000 US consumers to understand how AI is influencing the buying journey. The findings reveal a clear pattern: shoppers use AI tools to explore options, but they continue to rely on human-driven content before making a purchase.

Here is what the data shows:

• Less than 10% of shoppers click AI-recommended links

• Nearly 87% discover products on social platforms or blogs before purchasing on marketplaces

• Review sites rank higher in trust than AI assistants

Download the full report to see what this shift means for brands navigating the AI era.

Is this a business… or a tradition in disguise?

At first glance, this looks like a clean little arbitrage. Buy artificial Christmas trees cheap in the summer. Sell them for way more in December. Seasonal demand, predictable window, nice margins. Done.

But the more you sit with it, the less it looks like a normal business.

Because the moment you optimize it too hard, it breaks.

If you jack prices to the absolute max, you stop being “the friendly tree lot” and become “that guy selling plastic trees from his driveway.” If you add too much polish, it feels corporate. If you scale it across towns, it loses the charm. The magic isn’t the trees. It’s the ritual.

This idea works because it feels like a tradition that accidentally makes money.

That creates a real identity tension.

One version of the founder says:
“Let’s maximize margin. Premium trees. Upsells everywhere. Limited supply. Artificial scarcity.”

The other version says:
“No. Price them almost too fairly. Leave money on the table. Make people feel like they’re in on something.”

And here’s the uncomfortable truth: the second version probably wins long-term.

People don’t come back because the trees are the cheapest. They come back because this becomes the place. The one with hot chocolate. The one where kids help carry trees. The one you talk about at Thanksgiving.

That’s not a growth strategy. That’s a memory strategy.

Now let’s talk about scaling, because this is where most founders mess it up.

If you scale this like software, you kill it. A “Christmas Tree Rollup” is the fastest way to drain the soul out of it. Centralized branding, standardized pricing, paid ads and suddenly it feels like a pop-up mall kiosk.

But if you don’t scale at all, you’re leaving value on the table.

So maybe the right question isn’t “how big can this get?”
It’s “how many places can this feel local?”

The best version of this business doesn’t try to be the biggest tree seller. It tries to be someone’s tree seller. That’s a very different goal.

Which brings us back to the core question.

Is the goal to maximize profit?
Or to become “the tree place everyone goes to”?

If you chase profit, you get one good season.
If you chase tradition, you get repeat customers, word of mouth, and something weirdly durable.

Most startups are allergic to leaving money on the table.
This one might only work if you do.

And that’s what makes it interesting.

Pick one. Regret the other two.

You only get to open one.

• The NTE Pro idea you’d pitch immediately to a smart friend
• The NTE Pro idea you’d laugh at… then think about all day
• The NTE Pro idea that feels small until you actually do the math

All three are live inside NTE Pro right now.

NTE Pro is a growing database of 6,500+ startup ideas founders quietly argue with themselves about.
New ideas added daily. No trends. No fluff.

Make the wrong choice.

One More Meme