GM. This is Needs to Exist (aka NTE), delivering you a startup idea that finally diversifies startup employee equity.

NTE Pro gives you access to 6,500+ startup ideas, click if you like unfair advantages.

WhoFiled surfaces the signals behind new funding, sign up if you want to see deals before they spread.

Check out all the past newsletters here

Here’s what we’ve got for you today.

• Daily Idea - Startup Equity, Diversified

• Cap Table Courtroom

Why Employees Gamble Their Net Worth

The One Liner

Turn stock options into portfolios

The 140 character tweet (or X) version

Startup employees shouldn’t bet everything on one logo. Pool options, diversify risk, and turn fragile equity into a real portfolio.

The Longer Story Version

The Problem

Startup employees are told they’re “building wealth,” but what they’re really doing is concentrating risk.

One company.
One outcome.
Four-year lockup.

If it works, great.
If it doesn’t, you spent years trading cash comp for a spreadsheet.

Everyone knows this is irrational.
But there’s no real alternative.

You can’t sell early without stigma.
Secondary is opaque, slow, and favors insiders.
Advice usually sounds like cope: “believe in the mission.”

Public market employees diversify day one.
Startup employees are forced into faith-based finance.

That tension sits quietly in every Slack channel after layoffs.

The Solution

Reframe stock options as assets, not identity.

Employees can pool a portion of their options with other employees across different startups.
You keep upside in your own company, but you also gain exposure to a basket of others.

Under the hood, options are scored and weighted like a credit rating, but for private equity risk.
Stage, dilution, investor quality, velocity, downside protection.

It doesn’t replace your belief in your company.
It hedges it.

Instead of one binary outcome, you own a diversified slice of startup reality.

Why now
The contradiction finally snapped.

Layoffs made paper wealth feel fake.
AI made company trajectories faster and harder to predict.
Secondary markets stayed closed while risk went up.
Employees became more financially literate than the systems built for them.

People now understand diversification.
They just haven’t been allowed to apply it to startup equity.

That gap didn’t exist culturally five years ago.

⚠️ Challenges
This scares lawyers.
It scares companies who like retention via concentration.
Valuation and fairness are easy attack vectors.
Liquidity timing is messy.

But the MVP is clean.

Start small.
Voluntary participation only.
Early-stage employees who already think in portfolios.
Pool exposure, not control.

No trading frenzy.
No speculation theater.
Just risk smoothing.

How we’d build it

phase 1: prove demand
lightweight pooling contracts
simple risk bands instead of precise pricing
manual matching behind the scenes
use vibe-coded workflows with tools like retool + gpt to score and simulate portfolios

phase 2: trust and signal
introduce standardized scoring (the “credit rating” moment)
partner with a few trusted law firms and funds
private dashboards showing exposure, not prices
limited liquidity events, not continuous trading

phase 3: scale responsibly
automated matching and rebalancing
company-level opt-ins as a benefit, not a threat
broader baskets by role, stage, or sector
distribution through payroll, equity platforms, and employee finance tools

Why it needs to exist
Because the smartest people in tech understand diversification everywhere except where it matters most.

This doesn’t make startup equity safer.
It makes it honest.

It turns blind faith into structured risk.
And that’s how financial systems mature.

The Cap Table Courtroom

Court is in session.

Today’s defendant:
An idea that lets startup employees pool stock options and diversify risk.

The Prosecutor steps up first.

“This kills retention.
Golden handcuffs exist for a reason.
If employees can hedge their upside, they’ll leave faster, care less, and treat startups like short-term trades.
Equity is supposed to align incentives, not become a mutual fund.”

Strong opener. Juries like fear.

The Defense responds.

“Concentration risk isn’t alignment.
It’s coercion with better branding.
Public market employees diversify day one.
Startup employees are forced into single-stock bets with four-year lockups and no liquidity.”

They pause.

“If an employee can’t manage risk without quitting, the incentive system is already broken.”

The room shifts.

Now the Judge asks the uncomfortable questions.

Is forcing concentration actually exploitative?
If diversification is basic financial literacy, why is it forbidden here?
And if this truly ‘breaks retention’… why do companies need fragility to keep people?

The Prosecutor fires back.

“Founders take risk too. This dilutes belief.”

The Defense counters.

“Founders choose concentration.
Employees inherit it.”

Silence.

Verdict time.

The court can’t agree.

This idea probably scares lawyers.
It definitely scares bad retention strategies.
But it also feels… inevitable.

Because the smartest people in tech already know this truth everywhere else in their finances.

So the question isn’t “should this exist?”

It’s “how long can it not?”

Poll:

The 3 Ideas That Broke Our Group Chat

Three ideas inside NTE Pro caused real arguments this week.

Not hype arguments.
Actual “wait… are we allowed to do this?” arguments.

One idea got: “This is illegal, right?”
Another got: “I hate this… but it would work.”
The third got: “Why doesn’t this already exist?”

That’s usually how the good ones start.

NTE Pro isn’t a list of safe ideas.
It’s the place where the ideas feel slightly wrong before they feel obvious.

If you like seeing what smart people argue about before Twitter agrees,
sign up for NTE Pro.

WhoFiled Pro helps you stop chasing deals and start noticing them.

Add the companies or theses you care about.
WhoFiled Pro watches new filings, quietly filters the noise, and surfaces startups that actually match how you think.

No dashboards to babysit.
No endless browsing.

Just a personalized stream of “this matters to you” signals - delivered automatically.

WhoFiled Pro is free for a limited time.
Set it up once, then let the deals come to you.

One More Meme